The Leading FFXIV Gil Seller - Uffxiv.com!

If you're designing around avoidance tanks, Random Number Generator is going to screw people over way too often. So, you're kind of pigeonholed into mitigation tanks (which all the tanks in FFXIV are).

Dark Knight (Final Fantasy XIV) could be a DoT damage tank

The problem is there aren't many good ways to diversify tanks. If you have experience with tanking across multiple MMORPGs, this is immediately obvious.

 

Mitigation vs. avoidance tanks isn't really a debate. If you're designing around avoidance tanks, Random Number Generator is going to screw people over way too often. So, you're kind of pigeonholed into mitigation tanks (which all the tanks in FFXIV are).

 

And, if you're diversifying based on magic vs. physical, you're also doing it wrong. A group's tank player should not be forced to gear and level 2 different tanks just to contribute to his group in an equal way. Especially with the way esoterics currently work.

 

No player should be forced into a bad position purely because of their decision to play a certain job.

 

Ideally you want to make sure the fundamentals are equal -- so all the tanks need to be able to live through the baseline damage, all tanks need to be able to hold aggro over healers and DPS. If you're going to make DPS such an integral part of the job, then that should be equal, too. Those are the fundamentals. And, when I say equal, I do not mean the same.

 

As for how you diversify, you do it through style and flavor. So, WARs could be the burst damage tank, Paladins could be the sustained damage tank, Dark Knights could be a DoT damage tank. WARs can have a stance system with ramping effectiveness like what they have now. Paladins could have a stance system with sustained benefits. Dark Knights could have a stance system with better upfront gains but more upkeep. WARs could have a lot of bursty self-healing, Paladins could have weaker but targeted healing, Dark Knights could have steady and consistent self-healing. They could all bring equal but different buffs / debuffs. They're actually pretty even in this regard except there needs to be more options for the Strength debuff and Path stacking needs to be addressed in some way.

 

So you would have 3 very stylistically different tanks. The rest is just flavor -- Warriors being the more raw, brutish brawlers, Paladins being the righteous knights, Dark Knights being the edgy vigilantes.

 

At this point, this is all pointless rhetoric. Square Enix has already made their decisions. The most we can do is watch them tweak the numbers to achieve an ever fluctuating balance. I highly doubt we're going to see any large design shifts with the jobs any time soon.

Related News
07
Jul

Final Fantasy XIV Patch 3.01 How Best to Use the New Ninja Skills

Final Fantasy XIV Patch 3.01 will introduce the new raid dungeon Alexander: Gordias along with several adjustments to job actions, and address several known issues.Final Fantasy XIV Patch 3.01 How Best to Use the New Ninja Skills

12
Oct

My only concern for this is literal ffxiv gil farming for rare mats such as glaze nuts

This is nitpicking, but I just wanted to clarify your ideas a little more and throw out some case studies for consideration. Keep in mind, these are largely rhetorical. i'm not expecting a solid answer to any of these, but it simply shows how complicated it is.

14
Oct

Final Fantasy XIV Dungeon Guide: Hell House Mechanics

Hell Bomber—Targets a healer, and shoots up to 10 bombs in that direction in a straight line. The closer the healer, the less bombs fired. The AoE is nearly impossible to dodge unless already moving, or using fists of wind/ninja trait.

20
Aug

Parties kicking for squabbles is nothing new in the FFXIV Duty Finder

Anyways, that's my two cents and a nice chunk of text, tanks denying full clears and parties kicking for squabbles is nothing new in the FFXIV Duty Finder

13
Aug

FFXIV Dragoon has issues with Wheeling Thrust being

I mean, I get having story mode's gear being good for savage and all, but if the system were different such that Alexander story mode was released in FFXIV 3.1 Patch

19
Oct

Questions about the Garlean Empire

Each legion is headed by a general, or Legatus; they're modeled after the legions of the Roman Empire. Gaius led the XIVth Imperial Legion, again, because Final Fantasy XIV

Leave A Reply

Final Fantasy XIV Top News